Boy Scouts welcome 9 year old transgender member?

A nine year old girl was recently admitted as a member of the Boy Scouts, making her the first transgendered girl to do so.

In itself, the fact that a nine year old can be considered transgendered is somewhat distressing and disconcerting.

At that age, a nine year old does not have the mental maturity and capabilities to be able to make such a life-altering choice at that age.  It is naive to take what they have to say at face value as their brains have not yet fully developed.  A nine year old cannot possibly be able to discern from that age, that they will identify as the opposite gender for the rest of their lives. To label them as transgendered, is irresponsible.  A parent should let the kid live their life, until they are somewhat matured and are properly able to make that decision.  At nine, you do not have the mental maturity to understand everything about sexual organs, biology, etc, so it is silly to assume they can fully comprehend what it means to be transgendered.

At 9 years old, you might have boyish interests as a girl; that does not mean however, the child absolutely identifies as a girl/boy for the rest of their lives.  Parents should let their brains naturally develop before imposing certain beliefs which can stunt or alter their growth.

Here’s the article for context:

Associated Press

MAPLEWOOD, N.J. (AP) — A New Jersey boy has become the first openly transgender member of the Boy Scouts one week after the Boy Scouts of America changed its policy to allow transgender children to join the organization.

“I am accepted,” Joe Maldonado said Tuesday night as he put on a Cub Scout uniform.

The 9-year-old joined Pack 20 in Maplewood following the organization’s decision to allow transgender scouts. Maldonado had been banned from a Cub Scout group in Secaucus before the policy change.

“This is fun; I’m so proud,” he said during the meeting.

Scout leader Kyle Hackler taught Maldonado the Cub Scout salute and oath.

“This means you’re the same as Scouts all over the world,” Hackler told Maldonado.

The scout’s mother, Kristie, said she was “proud of the fight” she had put up after the Northern New Jersey Council of Boy Scouts last year told her Joe would not be allowed to continue to be a member of Pack 87 in Secaucus.

The Boy Scouts changed their policy of referring to the gender on birth certificates to determine eligibility last week after Maldonado’s story gained national attention.

The Boy Scouts of America decided in 2013 — after heated debate — to allow openly gay youth as scouts. The Scouts lifted a blanket ban on gay troop leaders and employees in July 2015 amid intense pressure.

The national Girl Scouts organization, which is not affiliated with the Boy Scouts, has accepted transgender members for years.

The Boy Scouts released a statement welcoming the Maldonado family. “Moving forward, the BSA will continue to work to bring the benefits of our programs to as many children, families and communities as possible,” the statement said.

Maldonado told the newspaper she had decided to bring her son to Maplewood because she did not want to go back to Secaucus, where she said scouting officials told her some parents had complained last year.



About Jake Beaumont 58 Articles
BA in Media Studies from the University of Guelph. Graduated from the University of Guelph-Humber with a Diploma in Journalism. Former Research Analyst for Honest Reporting Canada. Published in the Huffington Post, Vancouver Province and many other newspapers across Canada. Specializes in Middle-East politics. Currently situated in Toronto.

1 Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.